Arminfo.info



 Tuesday, August 18 2020 20:55
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Russian expert: Power in Belarus turned out to be too simple for a  complex society

Russian expert: Power in Belarus turned out to be too simple for a  complex society

ArmInfo. One should not hastily consider the processes in Belarus in the light of a color revolution - it is rather a protest movement caused by both internal  and external reasons. A similar opinion was expressed by political  scientist, associate professor at the Russian State University for  the Humanities, expert of the Russian International Affairs Council  Alexander Gushchin in an interview with ArmInfo correspondent.

"The first reason for these processes is psychological fatigue from  the 26-year rule of one person. It is clear that this government was  and is rather personalized, to a certain extent, authoritarian in  nature. This is not a totalitarian regime, and it does not permeate  all fields of public life, but it is a personified paternalistic  regime, and the society is to a certain extent tired from the  discourse of communication with it, "the political scientist  believes.

At the same time, the expert believes that this is primarily due to  the fact that generations have changed, and what was good in terms of  communication with society in the 90s, when Lukashenko achieved great  results in the fight against crime, with the preservation of the  state's industrial potential, does not work today. "No matter how  much Lukashenko is criticized now that the system is hardened and  there are contradictions with Russia within the EAEU, this system to  some extent had contributed to social stability, since it provided  employment for the majority of the population of Belarus," the  political scientist noted, adding that most of the Belarusian  factories have a surplus of labor, which is done to maintain social  stability.

At the same time, he added that in parallel with this, new social  strata were formed - the IT sector, the middle urban class - and as a  result, there is a generational conflict. "Under these conditions, it  seems to me that the government to a certain extent ceased to  correspond to the complex social system that had already formed in  Belarus. That is, the government turned out to be too simple for a  more complex society, and could not find these communication points  of contact.

The second point is the belatedness of constitutional reforms,  reforms of centralization and reforms towards collective leadership,  with the formation of party structures that could colonize public  sentiment, each in its own way. Even with the preservation of the  authoritarian leadership, this could have been done earlier,  "Gushchin believes.

The third omission, according to the expert, is foreign policy, since  recently the Belarusian multi-vector line has been replaced by some  tactical maneuvers. "And as a result, foreign policy partners from  both the East and the West were largely dissatisfied with these  maneuvers. We see that both in Russia and in the West, a number of  media outlets and the corporate structures supporting them express a  clear anti- Lukashensko position. Lukashenko promised too much, but  did little and there is no real progress, including in the direction  of the formation of the Union State, including on the roadmaps that  Russia proposed on its own initiative. The combination of these  factors played a role, "the Russian expert considers.

According to him, there is also a tactical factor, and after the  elections, few people believed that Lukashenko won the support of 80%  of voters. "It is another matter that the opposition was premeditated  not to recognize the election results. But the announced result  became a certain trigger and provoked public protests, which we  witnessed. The authorities' excessively harsh reaction to them was  also a provoking factor. There were, of course, provocations on the  part of the opposition, but the fact that excessive force was used  against the protesters played a decisive role, stirring up the  workers, in whom the protest from both social and psychological  fatigue, and protest against these disproportionate harsh measures,  was formed. The combination of these internal and external measures  led to a rather difficult situation faced today by the authorities,  "the political scientist noted, adding that the street is now under  the control of the opposition, and there are more and more people  gathering on it.

At the same time, Gushchin believes that, given the pressure from the  West, it will be quite difficult to keep this difficult situation  under control, despite the fact that the President of Belarus  announced his readiness to hold elections after the Constitutional  reforms, which is unlikely to satisfy the opposition.

The political scientist is also convinced that Russia is doing the  right thing by not taking open steps to intervene in the situation.  He stated that the President of the Russian Federation, in his  conversation with the German Chancellor, also stressed the  inadmissibility of external interference in the internal affairs of  Belarus. "But, external interference from the West, primarily from  Lithuania and Poland, is clearly visible.  It is, of course, veiled  under a social orientation, without obvious anti-Russian sentiments,  but there is a latent desire of certain circles in the future - and  there is this risk, the risk of reformatting the future geopolitical  vector. Of course, this will be done gradually, since color  revolutions do not immediately lead to changes in the foreign policy  vector'' Gushchin emphasized.

In his words, in the same Armenia, for example, one cannot say that  the foreign policy course has changed dramatically, but in general,  there are certain changes both among society and among young people  in relation to Russia. In the long term, public sentiment may change,  since there are many among the audience who are not pro-Russian, and  this concerns, first of all, the middle class, urban youth.

The political scientist sees certain political risks in these  processes. At the same time, he is convinced that today there is no  alternative to national dialogue, but the question arises who will do  this. Gushchin also believes that a lot will depend on whether  Lukashenko's supporters, of whom there are many, certainly not 80%,  but 40-50%, will be able to consolidate. According to him, today they  are seriously losing to the street and the opposition.

"In principle, this is a serious risk for the Union State, and  everything will depend on the further development of the political  situation. And here it is important to what extent external partners,  primarily Russia, Germany and China, will be able to reach a certain  consensus regarding the future of Belarus, in the sense of how they  will build their line on future reforms in Belarus, "he said,  expressing his conviction that other external partners, such as  Lithuania and Poland, play a more destructive role.

At the same time, Gushchin is convinced that after these processes in  Belarus, if Lukashenko remains in power, there is no need to talk  about any multi-vector approach, a lot will depend on whether the  power vertical in the country will be preserved, but he will not have  the former influence. National dialogue in the country will lead, one  way or another, to a change in the political system.

At the same time, Gushchin believes that the internal political  processes in Belarus will affect the integration projects in which  Minsk participates, since in parallel with this the Belarusian  economy will change. "But, it can not be stated that this will deal  some kind of critical blow to the Eurasian Economic Union, since even  from the point of view of relations with Russia, the Belarusian  economy is so much interconnected that any changes will be long-term  and sharp changes will lead to the collapse of the Belarusian  economic system. ", - the expert concluded.

To note, mass opposition protests began throughout Belarus on August  9, after the presidential elections, in which, according to the CEC,  incumbent head of state Alexander Lukashenko won 80.1% of the vote. 

READ ALL COMMENTS

Левон
Ко всему сказанному, мне кажется, можно было бы добавить, что в пользу г-на Лукашенко, при сравнении с положением г-на Януковича в 2013-м году, играет фактор и роль более слабой белорусской диаспоры. Украинская диаспора, как целая бандеровская армия, играла и играет несравнимо весомейшую роль до и после майданов на Украине. Да и личностные качества упомянутых деятелей, видимо, еще сыграет свою конечную роль. Накоенец, актуальный негативный пример Украины, в любом случае, весомый фактор при предполагаемой оппонентуре руководства республики с представителями оппозиции.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Gnel Sanosyan`s press office: Attributing  mansion to minister and  looking for manifestations of corruption are futile attemptsGnel Sanosyan`s press office: Attributing  mansion to minister and  looking for manifestations of corruption are futile attempts
Idram Junior and Koreez signed a memorandum of cooperationIdram Junior and Koreez signed a memorandum of cooperation
During the 33rd EBRD Business Forum, Ardshinbank hosted a panel discussion on economic and trade sanctions.During the 33rd EBRD Business Forum, Ardshinbank hosted a panel discussion on economic and trade sanctions.
Bagrat Srbazan: There is no alternative to resignation of current  government in ArmeniaBagrat Srbazan: There is no alternative to resignation of current  government in Armenia
Five Human Rights Defenders Initiative reports on illegal police  actions against citizens detained during protests in YerevanFive Human Rights Defenders Initiative reports on illegal police  actions against citizens detained during protests in Yerevan
Residents of border village of Kirants closed road to Georgia,  protesting border delimitation commission`s decisionsResidents of border village of Kirants closed road to Georgia,  protesting border delimitation commission`s decisions
Armenian FM meets with CoE Sec Gen in StrasbourgArmenian FM meets with CoE Sec Gen in Strasbourg
Investigative Committee of Armenia opens criminal case on police  actions in KirantsInvestigative Committee of Armenia opens criminal case on police  actions in Kirants
Azerbaijani puppet court extends illegal arrest of Ruben Vardanyan  for another 5 monthsAzerbaijani puppet court extends illegal arrest of Ruben Vardanyan  for another 5 months
Kakha Kaladze: Can you imagine our foreign minister would give speech at opposition rally let`s say, in Yerevan? Kakha Kaladze: Can you imagine our foreign minister would give speech at opposition rally let`s say, in Yerevan? 
Garnik Danielyan: Garnik Danielyan: "In this transition period,  Bagrat Srbazan is the  most acceptable candidate for premier post for me"
Mher Grigoryan: Baku is inclined to continue border delimitation  process in same format and with same algorithmMher Grigoryan: Baku is inclined to continue border delimitation  process in same format and with same algorithm
Armenia joins Oviedo ConventionArmenia joins Oviedo Convention
Border passes where it passes: Pashinyan spoke about Yerevan`s  principles and possible problems during delimitationBorder passes where it passes: Pashinyan spoke about Yerevan`s  principles and possible problems during delimitation
Russian expert on cleaning within Turkish Ministry of Internal  AffairsRussian expert on cleaning within Turkish Ministry of Internal  Affairs
Tavush for Motherland movement resumes protests Tavush for Motherland movement resumes protests 
CSI president writes letter of solidarity to Archbishop Bagrat  GalstanyanCSI president writes letter of solidarity to Archbishop Bagrat  Galstanyan
Azerbaijan extends arrest of former Karabakh leadersAzerbaijan extends arrest of former Karabakh leaders
Armenian PM reacts to attempted murder of Slovak counterpart Armenian PM reacts to attempted murder of Slovak counterpart 
Armenia, Azerbaijan sign Protocol-description of the borderline  sections Armenia, Azerbaijan sign Protocol-description of the borderline  sections 
Police opens road for participants of Tavush for Peace movementPolice opens road for participants of Tavush for Peace movement
Armenian Police intention to extend cordon around opera house caused  Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan`s anger Armenian Police intention to extend cordon around opera house caused  Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan`s anger 
This is dishonor to all of us -  archbishop about his compatriots  held in AzerbaijanThis is dishonor to all of us -  archbishop about his compatriots  held in Azerbaijan
Prime Minister of Armenia: Armenia-Azerbaijan borders delimitation  and demarcation process  should become one of the tools for Armenia  and Azerbaijan to learn to live peacefullyPrime Minister of Armenia: Armenia-Azerbaijan borders delimitation  and demarcation process  should become one of the tools for Armenia  and Azerbaijan to learn to live peacefully
Police chief: it was necessary to ensure safety of 2 thousand guests  who arrived at EBRD eventPolice chief: it was necessary to ensure safety of 2 thousand guests  who arrived at EBRD event
Bagrat Srbazan announces number of meetingsBagrat Srbazan announces number of meetings
Thousands of police officers were deployed near National Opera and  Ballet TheaterThousands of police officers were deployed near National Opera and  Ballet Theater
Poll: Over 50% of respondents do not see anyone as head of  transitional government in ArmeniaPoll: Over 50% of respondents do not see anyone as head of  transitional government in Armenia
FMO provided Ardshinbank with a guarantee for a credit portfolio of 20 million US dollarsFMO provided Ardshinbank with a guarantee for a credit portfolio of 20 million US dollars
Poll: More than half of respondents in Armenia positively assess  Poll: More than half of respondents in Armenia positively assess  "Tavush for Motherland" movement
RA MoD delegation participates in IDEB-2024 defense exhibition in  Bratislava RA MoD delegation participates in IDEB-2024 defense exhibition in  Bratislava 
Tavush for Motherland determined to hold protest in front of Opera  House Tavush for Motherland determined to hold protest in front of Opera  House 
Russia never offered Armenia complete withdrawal of frontier guards-  Maria Zakharova Russia never offered Armenia complete withdrawal of frontier guards-  Maria Zakharova 
Samvel Minasyan appointed commander of territorial defense forces Samvel Minasyan appointed commander of territorial defense forces 
The Power of One Dram Sums up the Two-Year Program with Teach for ArmeniaThe Power of One Dram Sums up the Two-Year Program with Teach for Armenia
Russian foreign ministry rep on warming of Armenian-Russian relations Russian foreign ministry rep on warming of Armenian-Russian relations 
Russian foreign ministry rep on USA, EU double standards in assessing  protests in Armenia, Georgia  Russian foreign ministry rep on USA, EU double standards in assessing  protests in Armenia, Georgia  
Police to block roads during EBRD forum in Yerevan Police to block roads during EBRD forum in Yerevan 
Azatazen organization issues statement on illegal detention of  co-founder, his comradesAzatazen organization issues statement on illegal detention of  co-founder, his comrades
Slovakia supports Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization Slovakia supports Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization 
Last year`s September events did not happen out of nowhere: Armenian  authorities recognized Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan - Russian Deputy  FMLast year`s September events did not happen out of nowhere: Armenian  authorities recognized Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan - Russian Deputy  FM
Inclusive dialogue within Inclusive dialogue within "3+3" platform and countering of  extra-regional forces` geopolitical dictatorship key to the  prosperity of South Caucasus - Mikhail Galuzin
Armenia, India to establish joint working group on bilateral defense cooperationArmenia, India to establish joint working group on bilateral defense cooperation
Tavush for Motherland movement will hold  protest rally on Freedom  Square tomorrowTavush for Motherland movement will hold  protest rally on Freedom  Square tomorrow
Azerbaijan is playing cat and mouse game with Armenia and the world -  analystAzerbaijan is playing cat and mouse game with Armenia and the world -  analyst
One of participants in peaceful protests in Yerevan suffered broken  leg due to disproportionate actions of Red Berets - StatementOne of participants in peaceful protests in Yerevan suffered broken  leg due to disproportionate actions of Red Berets - Statement
France, Civil Aviation Committee of Armenia sign technical  cooperation agreementFrance, Civil Aviation Committee of Armenia sign technical  cooperation agreement
Protection of Armenia`s borders with Iran and Turkiye will continue to be entrusted to Russian border guardsProtection of Armenia`s borders with Iran and Turkiye will continue to be entrusted to Russian border guards
Baku -Yerevan intensive negotiations resumed since Feb, Bayramov  saysBaku -Yerevan intensive negotiations resumed since Feb, Bayramov  says
President of Azerbaijan urges dissolution of OSCE MGPresident of Azerbaijan urges dissolution of OSCE MG
Beyond Filmmaking. PARAJANOV and FASHION Beyond Filmmaking. PARAJANOV and FASHION 
What is happening today on Yerevan`s streets implementation of  already introduced methods of struggle - clergyman What is happening today on Yerevan`s streets implementation of  already introduced methods of struggle - clergyman 
Armenian authorities launched psychological, moral and physical terror against their own people - clergyman Armenian authorities launched psychological, moral and physical terror against their own people - clergyman 
Actions of Actions of "red berets" against citizens during acts of civil disobedience clearly punitive in nature - Arman Tatoyan 
UN Committee against Torture is alarmed by extra-judicial killings,  torture and ill-treatment of Armenians by Azerbaijanis during armed  conflictsUN Committee against Torture is alarmed by extra-judicial killings,  torture and ill-treatment of Armenians by Azerbaijanis during armed  conflicts
Russian border guards leave Nerkin HandRussian border guards leave Nerkin Hand
Armenia to host 33rd EBRD Business Forum with flagship sponsorship of ArdshinbankArmenia to host 33rd EBRD Business Forum with flagship sponsorship of Ardshinbank
By PM`s decision, Sisian Boghossian relieved of her post as Tourism  Committee HeadBy PM`s decision, Sisian Boghossian relieved of her post as Tourism  Committee Head
All detained members of opposition movement have been releasedAll detained members of opposition movement have been released
NDP welcomes fact that it is Bagrat Srbazan who leads movement to  restore Armenian people`s dignityNDP welcomes fact that it is Bagrat Srbazan who leads movement to  restore Armenian people`s dignity
Read more



Commented