Arminfo.info



 Tuesday, June 2 2015 11:37

Степанян Դավիթ Stepanyan Ստեփանյան David Давид

Sergey Kurginyan: Russia's Responses to Azerbaijani and Armenian Impulses are Conditioned by the Rules of Geopolitical Market

Sergey Kurginyan: Russia

 What minuses and pluses are you tracing in Russia’s current Caucasian policy – particularly towards Armenia? What is your opinion on Moscow’s policy on the post-Soviet territory?  

After the collapse of the USSR we have been facing new rules of the reality. I believe that the new type of the Armenian-Russian relations can be built on the basis of our countries' national development only. Therefore, the optimality of the national development is to be Russia's only interest in the relations with Armenia. If this national development implies that Armenia is to have relations with any other country but not Russia, Moscow will simply have to accept it for it realizes there will be a configuration to meet the national interests. Taking into account the current realias and that sooner or later the society's impulses will decide everything, subduing or transforming someone makes no sense. One can contribute to the faster development of these impulses but never control them - this will result in counterreaction. It is another matter that most not only Caucasian but also European countries resemble pots with specific lids with a completely different content boiling inside. Most often these lids appear to be way more pro- Western than the boiling content they cover. In this case we should clearly differentiate the wakening of national spirit from globalism and the lid from the content.

 

Nevertheless, Armenia is a member of the Eurasian Economic Union. What tendencies are expected from Moscow towards Yerevan in this context? 

As I understand, modern Russia and Russian president's foreign policy is characterized by the attention they pay to the directions of their national interest - Armenia, for example, or any other state. This is the profile of Putin's policy, which is, properly speaking, not imperial. This policy is targeting at guessing tendencies, seeing where this or that nation and elite is intending to turn - this is for delicate consideration. If Armenia ever wishes to develop a good rapport with Turkey, let it be, it's Armenia's problem. As far as I know no one in Moscow will ever counteract this. They will simply deduce relevant conclusions and elaborate a certain line of conduct.  No one in Moscow will ever blame Armenia for treason. In other words, Russia builds one type of relations with countries of national interest and another type of relations with other countries. I believe that such a policy is normal.

 

 

What about Armenia’s national interests?

 

I cannot say for sure. Armenia's national interest is defined by its domestic conflicting groups and the political elite. I do understand the euphoria of the late 80s, the talks that Armenia would be the USA's foothold in Caucasus. British Petroleum and other companies' interest in the adjacent state shows that this never happened. This caused the new formation of the Armenian policy.  The time for hopes and unconditional utopias has passed. I don't blame anyone for Russia also had the same utopias once. I can't say that someone has gone mad and believed the USA. The Russian elite trusted them just the way other post-Soviet countries did.

 

 Many believe that the Karabakh conflict defines Armenia’s national interest. More people believe that Russia holds the key to the solution to this conflict…

I do not agree with people who say that Russia holds the key to the solution to the Karabakh conflict. I do not see that, therefore I do not share that misbelief. I would like to get evidence on Russia manipulating the Karabakh conflict. I wouldn't mind tht but I do not see it. Russia moves on in accordance with its own national interests - that is reciprocating the impulses of the adjacent territory. Therefore, Russia relevantly responds to both Azerbaijani and Armenian impulses. This reaction is a part of a peculiar geopolitical market. Here Russia monitors the development of tendencies by responding to reality and moving the wheel relevantly.  This is Russia's multi-vector nature. Kremlin realizes that neither Russian embassy, not residentura or Russian Armenians control Armenia.  The national elite, the complex alloy of elite and national tendencies control Armenia. I believe, Kremlin simply monitors the track of these tendencies.

 

 You have characterized some countries as pots with specific lids with a completely different content boiling inside. What boils in Armenia and what sort of a lid covers that pot?

 It is rather difficult to estimate this in case of Armenia. I keep an eye on Eastern European countries and I can assure you that this is happening in Bulgaria. I believe that Italy, Greece, Spain and even France will soon witness these processes. I think that in Ukraine everything has been split into several civilization modules each of which having different directions. The Greek “Sirisa” or Italian “5 Star” Movement speak about their nations’ discontent with their lids. Ythis means, there are direct indexes there, which I cannot tell I see in Armenia now. I see no bodies that express the dissent between the people and the elite. 

 

 The Armenian authorities were long aspiring for the European Association; meanwhile ordinary citizens were aspiring to join the Trade Union. Doesn’t this speak for the different content of the pot and lid?

 

 Might be. Then why has there been no relevant referendum held in Armenia?

 

Lausanne agreements on Iran's nuclear program have created new prospects for a new reality. How do you see this?

 I do not share the optimism about it. I do share the opinion of religious leader Khamenei, who said, "If you are so eager to conduct these talks, do that. Let's see what happens next." Naturally, we will be very glad to see progress in this matter.  However, my teammates and I do not believe in such rosy prospects.

 

Based on the existing phobias and the negative experience the Armenian society is rather concerned over the Russian-Turkish economic convergence. Do you share these concerns?

I think the Russian-Turkish relationship is much subtler than it seems to be. Generally speaking, the relationship with Turkey is an incredibly complicated process. That country is still on a crossroad.  It has not yet found its place in the world. The main economic projects with Russia are still being checked and tested. All this is being done very carefullyIf Russia sought to take Turkey's side; Russian President Vladimir Putin would not have attended the Armenian Genocide Centennial events in Yerevan on April 24. I would not say that Armenia's policy with respect to Turkey is not unambiguous either for there are various internal streams in Armenia. The notorious anti-Turkish sentiments in Armenia are not unlimited. We perfectly see pro-Turkish streams in the Armenian elite as well.  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Azerbaijanis destroyed Pantheon of Heroes of Stepanakert Azerbaijanis destroyed Pantheon of Heroes of Stepanakert 
Most powerful strategic positions in Tavush are being surrendered;  Constitution`s foundations are being undermined:  Former Justice  MinisterMost powerful strategic positions in Tavush are being surrendered;  Constitution`s foundations are being undermined:  Former Justice  Minister
RA MoD refutes information spread by Armenian social networksRA MoD refutes information spread by Armenian social networks
ANCA calls on US House of Rep  to expel Henry Cuellar over accepting  $598,000 in Azerbaijani bribesANCA calls on US House of Rep  to expel Henry Cuellar over accepting  $598,000 in Azerbaijani bribes
Anahit Manasyan still does not know how legal it is to restrict  rights to freedom of movement in border village of TavushAnahit Manasyan still does not know how legal it is to restrict  rights to freedom of movement in border village of Tavush
The Power of One Dram to the Road of Life Charitable OrganizationThe Power of One Dram to the Road of Life Charitable Organization
Zakharova: Armenia has not taken any new steps regarding CSTO  membership Zakharova: Armenia has not taken any new steps regarding CSTO  membership 
5 criminal proceedings were initiated on facts of torture in Armenia  in 2023 - Prosecutor General`s Office5 criminal proceedings were initiated on facts of torture in Armenia  in 2023 - Prosecutor General`s Office
Vassilis Maragos: Armenia`s media field continues to remain  polarized, despite positive trends in WPFIVassilis Maragos: Armenia`s media field continues to remain  polarized, despite positive trends in WPFI
EAFJD: Constant concessions cannot stop Azerbaijani maximalismEAFJD: Constant concessions cannot stop Azerbaijani maximalism
US reaffirms support for Armenia`s territorial integrity and  sovereignty US reaffirms support for Armenia`s territorial integrity and  sovereignty 
Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office sends application to prosecute  Pashinyan to NSS Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office sends application to prosecute  Pashinyan to NSS 
Rights and safety of Tavush population should be considered in border  delimitation and demarcation process - StatementRights and safety of Tavush population should be considered in border  delimitation and demarcation process - Statement
Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office initiates two criminal proceedings over  Azerbaijan`s aggression against ArmeniaArmenia`s Prosecutor`s Office initiates two criminal proceedings over  Azerbaijan`s aggression against Armenia
Poll: overwhelming majority of respondents in Armenia consider  celebrations dedicated to victory in WWII to be importantPoll: overwhelming majority of respondents in Armenia consider  celebrations dedicated to victory in WWII to be important
Armenia`s legal framework does not sufficiently protect freedom of  press - Reporters without bordersArmenia`s legal framework does not sufficiently protect freedom of  press - Reporters without borders
Armenian Genocide commemoration must be enshrined in Constitution -  poll Armenian Genocide commemoration must be enshrined in Constitution -  poll 
Most of respondents in Armenia not ready to co-exist with  Azerbaijanis- poll Most of respondents in Armenia not ready to co-exist with  Azerbaijanis- poll 
Ardshinbank CJSC has announced about the launch of a new  refinancing business loanArdshinbank CJSC has announced about the launch of a new refinancing business loan
No manifestations of apocalypse in law-enforcers` actions - NA  vice-speaker No manifestations of apocalypse in law-enforcers` actions - NA  vice-speaker 
Georgia turns down US invite for official visit over `pre-condition`Georgia turns down US invite for official visit over `pre-condition`
 Transitional dictatorship in Armenia - opposition MP Transitional dictatorship in Armenia - opposition MP
Not a single door in Armenia can be closed to a clergyman - Vahe  HovhannisyanNot a single door in Armenia can be closed to a clergyman - Vahe  Hovhannisyan
FMs of Armenia, Ukraine discuss current situation in regionFMs of Armenia, Ukraine discuss current situation in region
Armenian parliamentarians meet with Co-chair of Congressional  Armenian Issues Caucus in WashingtonArmenian parliamentarians meet with Co-chair of Congressional  Armenian Issues Caucus in Washington
WFP sees need to change format of assistance provided to Artsakh refugeesWFP sees need to change format of assistance provided to Artsakh refugees
Parliament`s opposition factions invite foreign diplomats to closed  meetingParliament`s opposition factions invite foreign diplomats to closed  meeting
Tatoyan: over 96% of respondents in Azerbaijan consider Armenia`s  Yerevan, Syunik and Sevan to be Tatoyan: over 96% of respondents in Azerbaijan consider Armenia`s  Yerevan, Syunik and Sevan to be "Azerbaijani lands"
Leader of Kamq movement: We have one task - Pashinyan`s resignation Leader of Kamq movement: We have one task - Pashinyan`s resignation 
Actions of authorities pose threat to Armenia`s stability and future  - political scientistActions of authorities pose threat to Armenia`s stability and future  - political scientist
Judge`s illegal actions proof of overt political persecution -  ex-minister of defense Judge`s illegal actions proof of overt political persecution -  ex-minister of defense 
Police actions in Kirants criminal - clergyman  Police actions in Kirants criminal - clergyman  
Struggle continues despite repressions - Suren PetrosyanStruggle continues despite repressions - Suren Petrosyan
Reports on alleged beating of residents detained in Kirants false -  Ministry of Interior Reports on alleged beating of residents detained in Kirants false -  Ministry of Interior 
Developments on Armenia`s borders result of concessive policy -  opposition MP Developments on Armenia`s borders result of concessive policy -  opposition MP 
U.S. Government watchdog group adds Azerbaijan to list of world`s   worst religious freedom abusers U.S. Government watchdog group adds Azerbaijan to list of world`s   worst religious freedom abusers 
Armenia`s premier on basis for Armenia-Azerbaijan border delimitation Armenia`s premier on basis for Armenia-Azerbaijan border delimitation 
"Tavush for the Motherland" movement calls on citizens to continue  acts of disobedience
Armenian authorities` actions in Kirants to have grave consequences -  opposition MPArmenian authorities` actions in Kirants to have grave consequences -  opposition MP
Armenia`s premier expounds on Armenia-Azerbaijan border delimitation  processArmenia`s premier expounds on Armenia-Azerbaijan border delimitation  process
$250mln package proposed for Armenian$250mln package proposed for Armenian
Police forces block roads leading to village of Kirants, bordering  AzerbaijanPolice forces block roads leading to village of Kirants, bordering  Azerbaijan
Armenia, NATO discussing prospects for expanding cooperationArmenia, NATO discussing prospects for expanding cooperation
Azerbaijan, Armenia confirm their participation in negotiations in  AlmatyAzerbaijan, Armenia confirm their participation in negotiations in  Almaty
Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs meeting has not yet been determined due to  lack of response from Armenia to this proposalArmenian, Azerbaijani FMs meeting has not yet been determined due to  lack of response from Armenia to this proposal
Omer Celik: Turkiye to monitor developments around Azerbaijan -  Armenia border agreement Omer Celik: Turkiye to monitor developments around Azerbaijan -  Armenia border agreement 
Peacekeepers` withdrawal from Karabakh continuesPeacekeepers` withdrawal from Karabakh continues
Mirzoyan told Al-Jazeera about Armenian-Azerbaijani normalization,  relations with Russia and expressed his position on situation in Gaza  StripMirzoyan told Al-Jazeera about Armenian-Azerbaijani normalization,  relations with Russia and expressed his position on situation in Gaza  Strip
Europe Nostra Vice President to visit ArmeniaEurope Nostra Vice President to visit Armenia
Acba Bank to start public placement of its next USD, AMD bonds on May  2Acba Bank to start public placement of its next USD, AMD bonds on May  2
Participation of the delegation of Turkmenistan in the 57th session of the UN Commission on Population and DevelopmentParticipation of the delegation of Turkmenistan in the 57th session of the UN Commission on Population and Development
MP: As a result of border delimitation Armenia to receive state  border to protect its sovereigntyMP: As a result of border delimitation Armenia to receive state  border to protect its sovereignty
Hungary blocks European Peace Facility`s support project for Armenia Hungary blocks European Peace Facility`s support project for Armenia 
RAU rector`s office term extended by 4 yearsRAU rector`s office term extended by 4 years
"5165" movement calls on all healthy forces of Armenia to unite for   salvation of motherland
Investigative Committee comments on beating of servicemen who  attended protests in KirantsInvestigative Committee comments on beating of servicemen who  attended protests in Kirants
Italian orchestra ROMA SINFONIETTA to perfom Ennio Morricone`s famous  compositions in YerevanItalian orchestra ROMA SINFONIETTA to perfom Ennio Morricone`s famous  compositions in Yerevan
Armenia`s government making unilateral concessions in Azerbaijan`s  favor - Tavush for the Motherland movementArmenia`s government making unilateral concessions in Azerbaijan`s  favor - Tavush for the Motherland movement
Armenia`s new rep to UNESCO appointed Armenia`s new rep to UNESCO appointed 
Border delimitation supposed to settle problems on other border  sectionsBorder delimitation supposed to settle problems on other border  sections
Read more



Commented