Arminfo.info



 Tuesday, December 15 2020 15:52
Alexandr Avanesov

Mikhail Piotrovsky: We must save the monuments after the war in  Karabakh

Mikhail Piotrovsky: We must save the monuments after the war in  Karabakh

ArmInfo. "I would refer to the word "ressentiment", which Nietzsche once suggested to us.Anger and irritation caused by disappointment and setbacks, the search for  the enemy responsible for their failures - this is the soil from  which this war was born, "said in an interview with RG, Director of  the State Hermitage, Academician Mikhail Piotrovsky, who addressed  with a kind of manifesto on the preservation of cultural monuments of  the Caucasus in difficult post-war times.

According to him, the issue of preserving monuments almost  immediately and actively sounded in the speech of the leader of  Russia. He recalled that in Karabakh Russian peacekeepers guard the  Dadivank monastery. The situation related to other monuments is  relatively calm. <But what is happening in them must be made the  subject of attention and news. It is necessary to create public  opinion protecting cultural monuments. If you want to impose  understanding on a variety of people: even if you hate this or that  people or religion, you should not touch cultural monuments. Because  history belongs to every nation. And cultural monuments - this idea  is the most important for me now - belong to humanity. They should  not be touched precisely because they are not someone's specifically,  but belong to everyone. And all of humanity, the whole world must  protect them. Whether in Syria, or in the Caucasus, everywhere,  "Piotrovsky stressed.

The academician pointed out the importance of convincing ordinary  people and politicians that cultural monuments are important almost  on a par with human lives. That their destruction is a crime. <I have  participated in several international discussions on this topic. Many  believe that international rules of intervention are needed to  protect monuments. So far, there is no integral global system for  protecting monuments. But it needs to be created. There are agreed  international positions on what to do when human rights are violated,  and when monuments are threatened, a scheme for monitoring what is  happening and responding to the threat should be worked out. It is  necessary to develop documents, prescribe a response mechanism and  seek the adoption of specific protective measures. I understand, but  this is a real dilemma.  During the war, an observation post was  almost always located on church bell towers. And what to do when  raising people to attack? To demolish the belfry with a shell, or to  leave it, risking the lives of people - this was the officer to  decide. Already in the Second World War, such questions were in all  armies. Teh same question is standing now, "he said.

According to Piotrovsky, each nation has its own roots and its own  cultural values. <I was born in Armenia.  Armenians, for example,  have almost mystical attitude to their own heritage - religion,  writing, manuscripts, architecture. They treat the alphabet as a  shrine. Western-oriented Armenians even arranged a provocative  discussion on the topic, that if they abandoned the Armenian  alphabet, took the Greek one, they would be more civilized and  already a part of Europe. But not coincidently in a plaque with the  Armenian alphabet made of gold is kept  Echmiadzin. Respect for  heritage is what brings people together.  And here I have to say one  more thought that is not obvious to many, but very important. You  will be able to understand and better perceive your cultural heritage  by well understanding someone else's. "Understand someone else's, and  you will understand yours" - this is my formula. The Hermitage  teaches us this, "the academician emphasized.

In his opinion, it is necessary to find "pain points" of threats to  monuments and talk and write a lot about this. <Do not take eyes off  the ancient monasteries - Dadivank and Gandzasar. Be attentive to the  mosques in Karabakh. And all the time - without emotion - to tell  what exactly is happening with the monuments. It is not so much to  blame "this is bad" as to present the full picture: this is the case,  this is the case. And to the conversations "Well, of course, they  protect their own", invariably answer that the cultural heritage is  always common>, the academician said. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Participation of the delegation of Turkmenistan in the 57th session of the UN Commission on Population and DevelopmentParticipation of the delegation of Turkmenistan in the 57th session of the UN Commission on Population and Development
Investigative Committee comments on beating of servicemen who  attended protests in KirantsInvestigative Committee comments on beating of servicemen who  attended protests in Kirants
Italian orchestra ROMA SINFONIETTA to perfom Ennio Morricone`s famous  compositions in YerevanItalian orchestra ROMA SINFONIETTA to perfom Ennio Morricone`s famous  compositions in Yerevan
Armenia`s government making unilateral concessions in Azerbaijan`s  favor - Tavush for the Motherland movementArmenia`s government making unilateral concessions in Azerbaijan`s  favor - Tavush for the Motherland movement
Armenia`s new rep to UNESCO appointed Armenia`s new rep to UNESCO appointed 
Border delimitation supposed to settle problems on other border  sectionsBorder delimitation supposed to settle problems on other border  sections
Armenia`s minister of defense hosts member of French Senate  CommitteesArmenia`s minister of defense hosts member of French Senate  Committees
Armenia`s authorities have nothing in common with Armenian people -  opposition MPArmenia`s authorities have nothing in common with Armenian people -  opposition MP
Leaflets calling for supporting Tavush residents distributed in  Armenia`s capital Leaflets calling for supporting Tavush residents distributed in  Armenia`s capital 
Armenia`s territories gradually surrendered under the guise of Armenia`s territories gradually surrendered under the guise of "pilot  border delimitation" - opposition MP
All-Armenian Council of Diplomats proposes solutions to end crisis in  Armenia All-Armenian Council of Diplomats proposes solutions to end crisis in  Armenia 
Statement by Armenia`s Ministry of Justice shameful - Arman Tatoyan Statement by Armenia`s Ministry of Justice shameful - Arman Tatoyan 
Armenia`s government comments on results of premier`s meeting with  residents of village of KirantsArmenia`s government comments on results of premier`s meeting with  residents of village of Kirants
Journalistic organizations expressed outrage at unjustified  aggression and cruelty of RA law enforcement officers against media  covering protestsJournalistic organizations expressed outrage at unjustified  aggression and cruelty of RA law enforcement officers against media  covering protests
Idram and IDBank at Career City FestIdram and IDBank at Career City Fest
"Shirak for Motherland" movement holds  car rally in Gyumri in  support of Tavush residents 
As of April 29, 2024, 35 border posts have been installed between  Armenia, AzerbaijanAs of April 29, 2024, 35 border posts have been installed between  Armenia, Azerbaijan
"Mother Armenia" bloc calls on students to stand up in support of  Tavush residents
European Commission Director General travels to South Caucasus to  launch new initiativesEuropean Commission Director General travels to South Caucasus to  launch new initiatives
Armenia`s Justice Ministry issues statement regarding  Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation in Tavush Armenia`s Justice Ministry issues statement regarding  Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation in Tavush 
Opposition MP files complaint against police Opposition MP files complaint against police 
When organizing Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Almaty,  Kazakhstan`s authorities will not act as negotiatorWhen organizing Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Almaty,  Kazakhstan`s authorities will not act as negotiator
Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office intends to reclassify actions of   defendants in case of March 1, 2008Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office intends to reclassify actions of   defendants in case of March 1, 2008
"Tavush for the Motherland " demands from Armenian law enforcement  agencies to investigate report accusing Bagrat Srbazan of committing  crime
Oppositionist: Turks seizing our lands step by step; Armenia`s  current authorities contribute to thatOppositionist: Turks seizing our lands step by step; Armenia`s  current authorities contribute to that
One of main problems of authorities` policy is to oppose history of  Armenian people - TatoyanOne of main problems of authorities` policy is to oppose history of  Armenian people - Tatoyan
Armenian FM holds talks with Speaker of the Shura Council of QatarArmenian FM holds talks with Speaker of the Shura Council of Qatar
One person, not Republic of Armenia protected now - opposition MPOne person, not Republic of Armenia protected now - opposition MP
Charles Aznavour a person of cosmic scale - Mkrtich MazmanianCharles Aznavour a person of cosmic scale - Mkrtich Mazmanian
Azerbaijani, Armenian FMs to meet in KazakhstanAzerbaijani, Armenian FMs to meet in Kazakhstan
Disobedience actions continue in Armenia Disobedience actions continue in Armenia 
Shift in Armenia s foreign policy not threat to Moscow - Tigran  BalayanShift in Armenia s foreign policy not threat to Moscow - Tigran  Balayan
Armenian premier. U.S. Sec of State discuss delimitation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border Armenian premier. U.S. Sec of State discuss delimitation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border 
U.S. Sec of State holds phone talks with Armenia`s premier,  Azerbaijani president U.S. Sec of State holds phone talks with Armenia`s premier,  Azerbaijani president 
Degradation of Tavush could start within 10 days - expert Degradation of Tavush could start within 10 days - expert
Prime Minister`s Cup must more and more closely linked with education  - Nikol Pashinyan  Prime Minister`s Cup must more and more closely linked with education  - Nikol Pashinyan  
Russia for further Armenian-Azerbaijani contacts - presidential spokesmanRussia for further Armenian-Azerbaijani contacts - presidential spokesman
Meeting of high-ranking officials of Armenia and Turkey took place in Tbilisi: the authorities are conducting negotiations behind Armenian people - expert Meeting of high-ranking officials of Armenia and Turkey took place in Tbilisi: the authorities are conducting negotiations behind Armenian people - expert 
Armenia`s leader forced into surrendering Homeland`s territories - clergyman Armenia`s leader forced into surrendering Homeland`s territories - clergyman 
Opposition MP critical of government over prosecution of servicemen Opposition MP critical of government over prosecution of servicemen 
Armenia`s premier addresses message on Citizen`s DayArmenia`s premier addresses message on Citizen`s Day
Russian embassy in Armenia reports events in commemoration of  Armenian Genocide victimsRussian embassy in Armenia reports events in commemoration of  Armenian Genocide victims
Servicemen join protesters in Tavush: criminal investigation launched Servicemen join protesters in Tavush: criminal investigation launched 
"Azerbaijan Sanctions Review Act" requires State Department to report on applicability of Magnitsky Act sanctions against Azerbaijani officials.
Law-enforcers use special means in Kirants: five hospitalized Law-enforcers use special means in Kirants: five hospitalized 
Int`l pressure must continue - David VardanyanInt`l pressure must continue - David Vardanyan
28 border posts have already been established between Armenia,  Azerbaijan28 border posts have already been established between Armenia,  Azerbaijan
Actions of disobedience continue throughout country: MP Artur  Khachatryan detained by brute force on Sevan-Yerevan highway Actions of disobedience continue throughout country: MP Artur  Khachatryan detained by brute force on Sevan-Yerevan highway 
Armenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest actionArmenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest action
Converse Bank bonds were bought in primary market within daysConverse Bank bonds were bought in primary market within days
Aliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, ArmeniaAliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, Armenia
MP: In many cases, deminers refuse to carry out demining in TavushMP: In many cases, deminers refuse to carry out demining in Tavush
Armenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperationArmenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperation
Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official 
Closing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  AghdamClosing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  Aghdam
Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  
India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism 
Armenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in TavushArmenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in Tavush
May One procession to take place in Yerevan May One procession to take place in Yerevan 
Armenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s bordersArmenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s borders
Read more



Commented