Arminfo.info



 Thursday, October 27 2016 18:29
David Stepanyan

Kiro Manoyan: With all discontent with Russia related to Crimea and Ukraine, the West cannot disregard its role and efforts in the Middle East 

Kiro Manoyan: With all discontent with Russia related to Crimea and Ukraine, the West cannot disregard its role and efforts in the Middle East 

In an interview with ArmInfo, Head of ARFD Bureau's Hay Dat and Political Affairs Office Kiro Manoyan speaks about the reasons and essence of the of latest developments in Syria, specifies the sides to the conflict and their interests, as well as explains why a new wave of “cold war” is impossible in the current situation and comments the Nagorno-Karbakh peace process.

A brief question that anticipates a comprehensive answer – what is happening in Syria now?

The reasons that sparked the conflict in Syria in 2011 were generally domestic political. It was continuation of the Arab Spring. Later, the domestic political demands of Syrians have been distorted dramatically and even replaced with interests of foreign powers. Eventually, what is happening in Syria now is rather a proxy war where third countries and forces are settling their own problems, while the Syrians and Syria are paying a high price for it. 

Do you mean collision of interests of U.S. and Russia?

I mean Turkey and Saudi Arabia, first. However, Russia and U.S. pursue and protect their own interests in the Syrian conflict. Nevertheless, Russia was directly involved in the Syrian conflict quite late. In this light, it is not easy to expect the conflict to end soon, much less to forecast anything. I am sure that the conflict would not last that long and would not become tragedy for the people of Syria, if it were connected with the problems of Syrians only. Besides Turkey and Saudi Arabia, the conflict has involved Qatar. All these countries seek to reduce Iran’s influence in Iran. Turkey seeks to make Kurds weaker in Syria. Declaring a fight against the Islamic State, Ankara did everything to make that terrorist organization stronger in Syria at the same time. Iran, in turn, does not want to see in Syria a force that would be acting against it in the future. Neither Hezbollah, a force influential in Lebanon, does. As for U.S., it has changed its policy in the region repeatedly during the last 5 years. At present, Washington comprehends that Assad is just part of the problem subject to settlement. Its approaches now greatly depend on the approaches of other countries, including Turkey and Saudi Arabia. Russia had to interfere in the crisis in Syria, otherwise its interests would remain in the background of the Middle East processes. There are other actors too, but Russia showed that it is present in Syria and will remain there.  I cannot say the same about U.S. To retain its influence in the Middle East, Russia needs to be present in the Mediterranean too. To that end, it needs the Syrian ports.

Do you mean that the main confrontation in Syria is between Sunnites and Shiites?

It is just one of the main directions involving Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Qatar on one side and Iran and Hezbollah on the other side. Yet, for Turkey there is another dimension of the conflict  - most of the Kurds are Sunnites, not Shiites.

Did Turkey intervene in Syria to “create a 5,000square km area of safe zone” as it had declared or Ankara, in fact, pursues other goals?

It is note ruled out that Turkey will control that 5,000 square km area for a longer time. Ankara had been insisting on the establishment of such no-fly zone to settle Syrian refugees for a long time already, though 5,000km is too much for that. I think Turkey tries not to let Kurds take control of that area. In the future, I think, Ankara will do everything possible to settle those territories with Syrians to “drive a wedge into” the territory controlled by Syrian Kurds.  

Is there still a risk for Turkey to face establishment of a Kurdish State in the territory of Syria, Iraq and Turkey amid de-facto war in Syria and Iraq?

Independence of Iraqi Kurdistan is still the most probable scenario. However, neither Turkish nor Syrian Kurds mull independence. Anyway, they do not speak about it, unlike Iraqi Kurdistan, though the authorities there have internal political discrepancies.

Are there any links between the military actions in Aleppo and Mosul?

I am not sure in it, considering that in Aleppo there are supporters of not only Al-Nusra Front, but also of other groups. At present, about twenty thousand people in Aleppo are in condition of hostages and are used as human shield against attacks of the Syrian Army that seeks to take control of Aleppo and weaken the positions of both terrorists and opposition.

Is it a new round or wave of “cold war”?

I do not think so. One should talk about new round of "cold war" in the light of latest developments in Syria. In conditions of "cold war" existence of the OSCE Minsk Group or cooperation between the presidents of France and Russia would become impossible. Maybe the current developments somehow remind the years of the “cold war”, however nowadays everything, particularly the interests, are so closely bound that even mutual sanctions will not lead to final breach in relations.

This especially relates to Russia, which as an international factor, is not only strong and powerful but also a responsible state. In case Russians were not involved in Syria and even Iraq, one would have to guess who would solve the main issues there. With all discontent with Russia related to Crimea and Ukraine the West cannot disregard its role and efforts in the Middle East. 

Considering that James Warlick speaks mostly about the package settlement-scheme for Karabakh and Moscow – about the stage-by-stage option, the stances of the OSCE MG co-chairs seem to have differed certainly…

U.S. Co-Chair Warlick has been talking about phased settlement of the conflict since 2014 urging the sides and the counterparts to sign a comprehensive agreement based on existing proposals and arrangements.  Meanwhile, prior to that, logic of the talks was quite different envisaging achievement of final agreement on all the fundamental issues and development of a comprehensive agreement only after that. 

By April 2016, even Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov started talking in Baku about phased settlement. Today everyone has realized the danger of such talks, and statement made by Russian Co-Chair Popov about inadmissibility of discussing exclusively the issue of territories testifies to that.  Warlick now agrees with him, stating about inadmissibility of discussing the issues of territories and status separately. As a result the Co-Chairs themselves have returned to the initial logic of negotiations. Actually, Matthew Bryza was long ago stating that lack of agreement on one issue means lack of agreement on all the remaining issues.

Since there is no agreement on all issues, can we say that the sides still negotiate just to negotiate?

In conformity with the statements of the mediators that are in harmony with the statements of the Armenian side, the negotiations are now held around mechanisms of control over ceasefire violations and to strengthen the ceasefire. The negotiations are not held around the matter point of the problem.  

What are the main threats to the Armenian stance on Karabakh?

 I think, first of all, we need to consolidate our stands, so that external forces have no temptation to use possible loopholes. We cannot afford weakening from inside and constant need in unity. There is no doubt that the Armenian people showed such unity in April. Neither there is any doubt that the July events involving Sasna Tsrer (Daredevils of Sasoun) group was an attempt by external forces to affect that atmosphere. And they managed to do it in some degree. The unity of the people should be ensured through respecting, not infringing, their rights. The people and the authorities should unite at least when it comes to Artsakh’s issue.  I see an external threat in Azerbaijan’s stance, especially after its April attempt to launch larger-scale violations on the line of contact. I think regular shelling and raids by Azerbaijan’s Armed Forces may create premises for a large-scale war. At the same time, I think the co-chair-countries together or separately may try to exert pressure on Armenia, but I do not think that Armenia will not be able to resist that pressure.

Will the current thaw in the relations of Russia and Turkey increase that pressure?

Today Russia and Turkey try first to rehabilitate trade relations, including through implementation of the Turkish Stream. And despite that fact, in a case of long-term operation this pipeline will obtain a geopolitical significance for the West. At this stage of the project, the Turkish Stream appears just and only as an economic project. There are no consolidated positions existing between Russia and Turkey regarding other issues and, to my view, there is no any shape of that yet. Anyway, Moscow keeps doing its best to isolate Turkey from the West. It is exactly with this purpose that the talks on the possibility of triple consultations on Nagorno Karabakh with participation of the Russian, Turkish and Azerbaijani Foreign Ministers are still being played up. But it is obvious also that the Karabakh problem could not be solved in the framework of such consultations and such format. Moreover, it is understood that going for such courtesy, Moscow tries to nurse Turkey and Azerbaijan. We shouldn't treat such attempts indifferently, but there is no reason for panic either, because there is only emptiness inside this mutual gallantry. One should not exclude the attempts of Russia to solve the Karabakh problem beyond Armenian sides to the conflict, but such attempts also have limits. Russia has own interests in Armenia. And Moscow's behavior is predicted exactly by those interests, and not by our charming eyes. It is absolutely normal and natural, but, being aware of this fidelity, we should understand that Russia's efforts to do a favor to Turkey and Azerbaijan will have certain limits, stipulated firstly by our point of view and by Russia's aspiration to protect own interests in Armenia. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Journalistic organizations expressed outrage at unjustified  aggression and cruelty of RA law enforcement officers against media  covering protestsJournalistic organizations expressed outrage at unjustified  aggression and cruelty of RA law enforcement officers against media  covering protests
Idram and IDBank at Career City FestIdram and IDBank at Career City Fest
"Shirak for Motherland" movement holds  car rally in Gyumri in  support of Tavush residents 
As of April 29, 2024, 35 border posts have been installed between  Armenia, AzerbaijanAs of April 29, 2024, 35 border posts have been installed between  Armenia, Azerbaijan
"Mother Armenia" bloc calls on students to stand up in support of  Tavush residents
European Commission Director General travels to South Caucasus to  launch new initiativesEuropean Commission Director General travels to South Caucasus to  launch new initiatives
Armenia`s Justice Ministry issues statement regarding  Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation in Tavush Armenia`s Justice Ministry issues statement regarding  Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation in Tavush 
Opposition MP files complaint against police Opposition MP files complaint against police 
When organizing Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Almaty,  Kazakhstan`s authorities will not act as negotiatorWhen organizing Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Almaty,  Kazakhstan`s authorities will not act as negotiator
Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office intends to reclassify actions of   defendants in case of March 1, 2008Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office intends to reclassify actions of   defendants in case of March 1, 2008
"Tavush for the Motherland " demands from Armenian law enforcement  agencies to investigate report accusing Bagrat Srbazan of committing  crime
Oppositionist: Turks seizing our lands step by step; Armenia`s  current authorities contribute to thatOppositionist: Turks seizing our lands step by step; Armenia`s  current authorities contribute to that
One of main problems of authorities` policy is to oppose history of  Armenian people - TatoyanOne of main problems of authorities` policy is to oppose history of  Armenian people - Tatoyan
Armenian FM holds talks with Speaker of the Shura Council of QatarArmenian FM holds talks with Speaker of the Shura Council of Qatar
One person, not Republic of Armenia protected now - opposition MPOne person, not Republic of Armenia protected now - opposition MP
Charles Aznavour a person of cosmic scale - Mkrtich MazmanianCharles Aznavour a person of cosmic scale - Mkrtich Mazmanian
Azerbaijani, Armenian FMs to meet in KazakhstanAzerbaijani, Armenian FMs to meet in Kazakhstan
Disobedience actions continue in Armenia Disobedience actions continue in Armenia 
Shift in Armenia s foreign policy not threat to Moscow - Tigran  BalayanShift in Armenia s foreign policy not threat to Moscow - Tigran  Balayan
Armenian premier. U.S. Sec of State discuss delimitation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border Armenian premier. U.S. Sec of State discuss delimitation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border 
U.S. Sec of State holds phone talks with Armenia`s premier,  Azerbaijani president U.S. Sec of State holds phone talks with Armenia`s premier,  Azerbaijani president 
Degradation of Tavush could start within 10 days - expert Degradation of Tavush could start within 10 days - expert
Prime Minister`s Cup must more and more closely linked with education  - Nikol Pashinyan  Prime Minister`s Cup must more and more closely linked with education  - Nikol Pashinyan  
Russia for further Armenian-Azerbaijani contacts - presidential spokesmanRussia for further Armenian-Azerbaijani contacts - presidential spokesman
Meeting of high-ranking officials of Armenia and Turkey took place in Tbilisi: the authorities are conducting negotiations behind Armenian people - expert Meeting of high-ranking officials of Armenia and Turkey took place in Tbilisi: the authorities are conducting negotiations behind Armenian people - expert 
Armenia`s leader forced into surrendering Homeland`s territories - clergyman Armenia`s leader forced into surrendering Homeland`s territories - clergyman 
Opposition MP critical of government over prosecution of servicemen Opposition MP critical of government over prosecution of servicemen 
Armenia`s premier addresses message on Citizen`s DayArmenia`s premier addresses message on Citizen`s Day
Russian embassy in Armenia reports events in commemoration of  Armenian Genocide victimsRussian embassy in Armenia reports events in commemoration of  Armenian Genocide victims
Servicemen join protesters in Tavush: criminal investigation launched Servicemen join protesters in Tavush: criminal investigation launched 
"Azerbaijan Sanctions Review Act" requires State Department to report on applicability of Magnitsky Act sanctions against Azerbaijani officials.
Law-enforcers use special means in Kirants: five hospitalized Law-enforcers use special means in Kirants: five hospitalized 
Int`l pressure must continue - David VardanyanInt`l pressure must continue - David Vardanyan
28 border posts have already been established between Armenia,  Azerbaijan28 border posts have already been established between Armenia,  Azerbaijan
Actions of disobedience continue throughout country: MP Artur  Khachatryan detained by brute force on Sevan-Yerevan highway Actions of disobedience continue throughout country: MP Artur  Khachatryan detained by brute force on Sevan-Yerevan highway 
Armenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest actionArmenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest action
Converse Bank bonds were bought in primary market within daysConverse Bank bonds were bought in primary market within days
Aliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, ArmeniaAliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, Armenia
MP: In many cases, deminers refuse to carry out demining in TavushMP: In many cases, deminers refuse to carry out demining in Tavush
Armenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperationArmenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperation
Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official 
Closing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  AghdamClosing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  Aghdam
Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  
India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism 
Armenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in TavushArmenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in Tavush
May One procession to take place in Yerevan May One procession to take place in Yerevan 
Armenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s bordersArmenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s borders
Contract serviceman injured in demining operations in TavushContract serviceman injured in demining operations in Tavush
Armenia today is in a particularly difficult situation and deserves  attention more than ever before - Jean-Luc MelenchonArmenia today is in a particularly difficult situation and deserves  attention more than ever before - Jean-Luc Melenchon
Driver blocks one of Yerevan`s tangled roadsDriver blocks one of Yerevan`s tangled roads
France is ready to expand framework of interaction with Armenia -  DevinazFrance is ready to expand framework of interaction with Armenia -  Devinaz
Ruben Vardanyan`s family persuaded him to stop his hunger strikeRuben Vardanyan`s family persuaded him to stop his hunger strike
20 border pillars have already been installed on Armenia-Azerbaijan  border 20 border pillars have already been installed on Armenia-Azerbaijan  border 
Freedom of speech is not highly valued in `bastion` of democracy: 7  people detained due to incident involving Premier`s wife in  TsitsernakaberdFreedom of speech is not highly valued in `bastion` of democracy: 7  people detained due to incident involving Premier`s wife in  Tsitsernakaberd
Armenia`s Parliament Speaker has not yet received letters from his  Federation Council partners Armenia`s Parliament Speaker has not yet received letters from his  Federation Council partners 
Current situation in region brings new challenges for both Armenia  and Syria - SpeakerCurrent situation in region brings new challenges for both Armenia  and Syria - Speaker
European Parliament: human rights violations in Azerbaijan are  incompatible with country`s preparations to host COP29European Parliament: human rights violations in Azerbaijan are  incompatible with country`s preparations to host COP29
"We are waiting!", Russian side expects Pashinyan`s participation in  EAEU summit
Protests in Armenia: roads, streets are closed; police use  disproportionate force to detain citizensProtests in Armenia: roads, streets are closed; police use  disproportionate force to detain citizens
Legitimate borders are very the guarantee of security that is talked  about a lot - RA NA SpeakerLegitimate borders are very the guarantee of security that is talked  about a lot - RA NA Speaker
Read more



Commented