Arminfo.info



 Wednesday, May 13 2020 11:43
David Stepanyan

Azerbaijani analyst: The essence of the Madrid principles lies in a  package-phased settlement

Azerbaijani analyst: The essence of the Madrid principles lies in a  package-phased settlement

ArmInfo.The well-known statement by Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov on Karabakh caused much ado about nothing in Armenia and Azerbaijan. Azerbaijani analyst Rauf Mirkadyrov expressed a similar opinion to ArmInfo.

"By and large, there was nothing new in Lavrov's statements except  one point. For the first time in many years, he recalled the  well-known four UN Security Council resolutions requiring the  liberation of the occupied territories, the opening of all  communications, ensuring the safety of civilians, and the return of  refugees to places of permanent residence, establishing economic and  diplomatic relations. However, he immediately made a reservation that  the only acceptable format for the implementation of the resolutions  is the institution of co-chairmanship of the OSCE Minsk Group, " he  stressed.

According to Mirkadyrov's estimates, by and large, the Madrid  principles are not an option for a phased settlement of the conflict,  as the above-mentioned UN Security Council resolutions and the  mandate of the Minsk Group require. In his opinion, in essence, the  Madrid principles imply a package-phased settlement, when all issues  are agreed in a package, but are implemented in stages.

Meanwhile, in the opinion of the Azerbaijani analyst, this  contradicts UN Security Council resolutions requiring at the first  stage eliminating the consequences of the armed phase of the conflict  without any connection with the determination of the final status of  Nagorno-Karabakh. The parties should have discussed the latter in  subsequent stages, more specifically at the Minsk Conference.

According to the analyst, Lavrov's mention of the well-known  resolutions with a stretch of imagination can be described as  pressure not even on Armenia, but personally on Prime Minister  Pashinyan, whom, according to Mirkadyrov, Moscow does not like. <On  the whole, the reaction turned out to be inadequate, both in Baku and  in Yerevan. At the same time, both in Baku and in Yerevan, they tried  to use Lavrov's statement and subsequent events to solve domestic  political problems,> he noted.

According to the analyst, the Armenian opposition behaved  consistently, but completely unreasonably, once again accusing  Pashinyan and his team of failure to negotiate. It is unfounded for  the simple reason that the Madrid principles were developed back in  2007 when Robert Kocharian was president. And all subsequent years,  Yerevan negotiated on the basis of these principles.

According to Mirkadyrov, the Azerbaijani opposition turned out to be  even more consistent, which did not react at all to the storm raised  by Lavrov in   tea cup. However, some representatives of the ruling  elite reacted, until recently, supervised by the clan of ex-head of  the presidential administration Ramiz Mehdiyev. According to them,  the Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov did not react  harshly to the reaction of his Armenian counterpart to Lavrov's  statements. "Some even accused Mammadyarov of sabotaging the  offensive policy of Ilham Aliyev in the Karabakh direction and  playing up to Armenia on the principle" the king is good, the retinue  is bad>. All this is a showdown within the ruling elite, nothing  more. In a word, nothing new is happening. All is quiet in Baghdad.  Naturally, if we are talking about the process of resolving the  Karabakh conflict, "Mirkadyrov summed up.

Since 1992, the OSCE Minsk Group, represented by the co-chairs from  Russia, the USA and France, has been engaged in the settlement of the  Karabakh conflict. Currently, the settlement process is nominally  based on the Madrid Principles put forward by the OSCE Minsk Group in  2007 in Madrid and the Madrid Principles updated in 2009, which  contain a phased and package settlement plan and deployment of a  peacekeeping contingent in the conflict zone. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Tokayev wrote an article for EuronewsTokayev wrote an article for Euronews
Armenia should be built in line with dreams of people and not of  groups considering themselves elites - Nikol PashinyanArmenia should be built in line with dreams of people and not of  groups considering themselves elites - Nikol Pashinyan
Armenia`s government declares disaster zones in communities of Lori  and Tavush Armenia`s government declares disaster zones in communities of Lori  and Tavush 
Armenia`s former human rights defender issues statement on Sardarapat  incident Armenia`s former human rights defender issues statement on Sardarapat  incident 
Each citizen plays role in outcome of confrontation between Tavush  for Homeland movement and Armenia`s authorities - ex-official Each citizen plays role in outcome of confrontation between Tavush  for Homeland movement and Armenia`s authorities - ex-official 
Group of MEPs concerned over methods of delimitation of  Armenia-Azerbaijan border Group of MEPs concerned over methods of delimitation of  Armenia-Azerbaijan border 
Georgia parliament overturns veto on foreign agents lawGeorgia parliament overturns veto on foreign agents law
Everyone must be responsible for their actions - Bagrat Galstanyan Everyone must be responsible for their actions - Bagrat Galstanyan 
Armenia`s premier reports 30% economic growth in Armenia since 2018Armenia`s premier reports 30% economic growth in Armenia since 2018
Work must be national ideology -Armenia`s premier Work must be national ideology -Armenia`s premier 
Issues of development of Turkmen-Kazakh relations were discussedIssues of development of Turkmen-Kazakh relations were discussed
Armenia s interior minister ready for meeting with Bagrat Galstanyan  in another formatArmenia s interior minister ready for meeting with Bagrat Galstanyan  in another format
Russia plans to open consulate general in occupied ArtsakhRussia plans to open consulate general in occupied Artsakh
Protests in Armenia have two components: objective and external -  political scientistProtests in Armenia have two components: objective and external -  political scientist
MP from MP from "Civil Contract": Pashinyan - Galstanyan meeting  is  impossible
54-year-old man who used tear gas against police detained in Yerevan54-year-old man who used tear gas against police detained in Yerevan
Converse Bank began issuing China UnionPay cards - UnionPay Gold and  UnionPay PlatinumConverse Bank began issuing China UnionPay cards - UnionPay Gold and  UnionPay Platinum
Police actions becoming increasingly gang-like, clearly indicating  loss of control over situation: David AnanyanPolice actions becoming increasingly gang-like, clearly indicating  loss of control over situation: David Ananyan
"Tavush for Motherland" supporters to celebrate First Republic Day in  Sardarapat
MFA: There are no foreign citizens among those injured or killed in  floods in northern ArmeniaMFA: There are no foreign citizens among those injured or killed in  floods in northern Armenia
Azerbaijani puppet court rejects Ruben Vardanyan`s complaint for  illegal arrestAzerbaijani puppet court rejects Ruben Vardanyan`s complaint for  illegal arrest
Armenian experts` delegation pays two-day visit to Kyiv Armenian experts` delegation pays two-day visit to Kyiv 
Gnel Sanosyan: problems caused by flood were unpredictableGnel Sanosyan: problems caused by flood were unpredictable
Major General: Armenia today is not ready to independently guard its  borders with Turkiye and IranMajor General: Armenia today is not ready to independently guard its  borders with Turkiye and Iran
Bagrat Srbazan`s bishopric rank preserved; his church-administrative  service terminated: AACBagrat Srbazan`s bishopric rank preserved; his church-administrative  service terminated: AAC
Nothing like this has been in modern Armenia: Nothing like this has been in modern Armenia: "The police were given  direct instructions to use brute force against parents of dead  servicemen, MPs  and media representatives"
Rivers subsiding in Armenia Rivers subsiding in Armenia 
Refusal of embassies to provide entry visas to Artsakh residents  violates Convention relating to Status of RefugeesRefusal of embassies to provide entry visas to Artsakh residents  violates Convention relating to Status of Refugees
Any state has right to do whatever it deems necessary not to others`  detriment - ambassador Any state has right to do whatever it deems necessary not to others`  detriment - ambassador 
Stepanakert mayor arrested Stepanakert mayor arrested 
Road leading to the border with Georgia passable in direction of  Yerevan-Sevan-Dilijan-Ijevan- Noyemberyan-Ptgavan-BagratashenRoad leading to the border with Georgia passable in direction of  Yerevan-Sevan-Dilijan-Ijevan- Noyemberyan-Ptgavan-Bagratashen
Danila Kozlovsky`s Frank show to perform in Yerevan Danila Kozlovsky`s Frank show to perform in Yerevan 
`Red berets` beat opposition MP in central Yerevan `Red berets` beat opposition MP in central Yerevan 
Belarusian ambassador to Armenia on his role in development of  bilateral relations Belarusian ambassador to Armenia on his role in development of  bilateral relations 
Floods in Armenia: Russia in contact with Armenian side Floods in Armenia: Russia in contact with Armenian side 
Clergyman Bagrat Galstanyan announces actions of disobedience Clergyman Bagrat Galstanyan announces actions of disobedience 
Tavush for Motherland movement leader ready to become Armenia`s  premier Tavush for Motherland movement leader ready to become Armenia`s  premier 
No threat of dam collapse in Armenia`s reservoirs  No threat of dam collapse in Armenia`s reservoirs  
Ex-official calls for `clearing country of evil`Ex-official calls for `clearing country of evil`
Our common objective is sustainable peace in South Caucasus - Josep  BorrelOur common objective is sustainable peace in South Caucasus - Josep  Borrel
Payment for Schengen visa for Armenian citizens to remain unchanged Payment for Schengen visa for Armenian citizens to remain unchanged 
Law-enforcers searching Stepanakert mayor`s home Law-enforcers searching Stepanakert mayor`s home 
Armenian premier`s security service remove journalist from school  building Armenian premier`s security service remove journalist from school  building 
Armenia supports Estonia in border incident with Russia - Estonian FMArmenia supports Estonia in border incident with Russia - Estonian FM
Armenian premier`s helicopter makes emergency landing in VanadzorArmenian premier`s helicopter makes emergency landing in Vanadzor
President confers military ranks on high-ranking officers President confers military ranks on high-ranking officers 
Azerbaijani, German FMs discuss Armenian-Azerbaijani peace process Azerbaijani, German FMs discuss Armenian-Azerbaijani peace process 
Martakert mayor detained Martakert mayor detained 
Azerbaijan increases military budget Azerbaijan increases military budget 
Armenia`s premier speaks of Real Armenia in his message Armenia`s premier speaks of Real Armenia in his message 
Armenia`s authorities resorting to pressure and disinformation in  dealing with Church - AACArmenia`s authorities resorting to pressure and disinformation in  dealing with Church - AAC
RA Human Rights Defender`s Office responds to video footage of  harassment of French- Armenian journalistRA Human Rights Defender`s Office responds to video footage of  harassment of French- Armenian journalist
Armenia`s top security official receives Louis BonoArmenia`s top security official receives Louis Bono
EU Ambassador to Armenia was presented with results of work carried out at Margara checkpoint on Armenian-Turkish borderEU Ambassador to Armenia was presented with results of work carried out at Margara checkpoint on Armenian-Turkish border
Minister of Health: process of introducing comprehensive health  insurance continues at high paceMinister of Health: process of introducing comprehensive health  insurance continues at high pace
Director of Pentagon`s DTRA CTR Directorate visits YerevanDirector of Pentagon`s DTRA CTR Directorate visits Yerevan
Davutoglu: Turkiye should quickly regulate its relations with ArmeniaDavutoglu: Turkiye should quickly regulate its relations with Armenia
Azerbaijan, which destroys monuments, urges UNESCO to `save` Kond -  StatementAzerbaijan, which destroys monuments, urges UNESCO to `save` Kond - Statement
Moscow accuses West of trying to undermine peace in  South CaucasusMoscow accuses West of trying to undermine peace in  South Caucasus
Zatulin: Pashinyan is trying to put all responsibility for losing war  with Azerbaijan in NK on RussiaZatulin: Pashinyan is trying to put all responsibility for losing war  with Azerbaijan in NK on Russia
Read more



Commented